Thursday, November 30, 2023
HomeContainersRival of Matson can proceed with antitrust lawsuit


To our FREE newsletter
Get all the latest maritime news delivered straight to your inbox.

Rival of Matson can proceed with antitrust lawsuit

Two Matson Inc subsidiaries must face claims from rival container shipping company American President Lines LLC that Matson is abusing its market power over service from the United States to Guam, a federal judge ruled in an antitrust lawsuit.

The ruling Friday by U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper in Washington, D.C., declined to dismiss claims against Matson Navigation Company Inc and Matson Logistics Inc brought by American President Lines last year seeking unspecified monetary damages for alleged violations of U.S. competition law.

The court dismissed parent company Matson Inc as a defendant.

Honolulu-based Matson, a leading U.S. carrier in the Pacific, in 2021 recorded revenue of more than $3.9 billion. Cooper said Matson Navigation provided the “ocean shipping services mainly at issue in this case” and Matson Logistics provided ground support.

The allegations against Matson “implicate quintessential antitrust injuries,” Cooper wrote.

A spokesperson for Matson declined to comment on Monday. Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher partner Rachel Brass, a lawyer for Matson, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A representative from American President Lines, a subsidiary of the French shipping and logistics company CMA CGM Group, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Monday. A lawyer at BakerHostetler who filed the lawsuit against Matson did not immediately respond to a similar request.

U.S. law says only American-owned vessel companies can transport containers between two U.S. ports. There is an exemption in the law that says non-U.S.-owned shippers can transport between the U.S. and Guam.

American President Lines said in its complaint that after it entered the market in 2015 for U.S. to Guam shipments, Matson took a series of anticompetitive steps to maintain its power. Matson has denied such conduct.

The complaint took issue with a loyalty program that offered discounts to cargo owners that shipped with Matson, and it said Matson “deployed an offensive of predatory threats to coerce shippers not to do business” with its rival.

Matson’s lawyers said in their court filings that “on the islands, where timely and consistent delivery is critical to everyday life, Matson is known for its reliability; [American President Lines] is known for its inconsistency.”

Attorneys said Matson said American President Lines was “trying to save face by making baseless allegations of anticompetitive conduct.”

Source: Reuters

Related Posts


Finance & Economy
Shipping News

Euronav: Dividend Distribution For Q3 2023 & Business Update

Euronav NV provides a business and dividend update following the recent board and management changes. The Supervisory board has agreed to distribute USD 0.57 per...

A new chapter for Euronav

Euronav shareholders have approved strategic changes at the company ushering in a new era.

TEN Reports Earnings Results for Q3 & 9M2023

Tsakos Energy Navigation Limited reported earnings results for the third quarter and nine months ended September 30, 2023. For the third quarter, the company reported...

StealthGas posts near-record quarterly profit

STEALTHGAS INC. (NASDAQ: GASS), a ship-owning company serving the liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) sector of the international shipping industry, announced today its unaudited financial...

Golar LNG Reports Third Quarter Net Income of $114 Million

Golar LNG announced its interim results for the period ended September 30, 2023. Highlights include: Golar LNG Limited (“Golar” or “the Company”) reports Q3 2023 Net...

Baltic index extends rally on higher capesize rates

The Baltic Exchange’s dry bulk sea freight index rose on Tuesday for the fourth...

CLIA presents cruise industry’s Action Plan for Greeceto the Greek Government

Representatives of Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA), members of the Government, and key stakeholders...

Baltic index scales 1 and 1/2-year peak

The Baltic Exchange’s dry bulk sea freight index rose on Monday for the third...

Greek merchant fleet up in numbers, down in volume

The Greek merchant shipping fleet rose in numbers but fell in volume in September. More...

Celestyal unveils 3 new countries and 6 new ports for 2024 & 2025

Celestyal the award-winning, number one choice for cruise travelers to the Greek islands and...

Port Houston Breaks Export Record

October was the biggest month ever for loaded exports at Port Houston, up 6% compared to last October. Port Houston’s loaded exports are up...

Port of Piraeus working on first shore power connection slots for 2024

The Piraeus Port Authority (PPA), which manages the largest and busiest port in Greece, announced the first five shore power connection slots for ferry...

Two major US cruise operators interested in buying Lavrio port

The tender for the concession of Lavrio port is set to begin in the next few weeks. Sources tell Kathimerini there are at least two...

Biden Administration Invests Over $650 mln in US Ports to Strengthen Supply Chains

The U.S. Department of Transportation’s Maritime Administration (MARAD) announced over $653 million to fund 41 port improvement projects across the nation under the Port...

APM Terminals & DP World spearhead roadmap for accelerating electrification of port operations in bid for net-zero

APM Terminals and DP World announced an initiative to accelerate decarbonisation of the world’s terminals through the widespread electrification of container handling equipment (CHE)....