Monday, February 6, 2023
spot_img
HomeEnvironmentHSFO demand firm as scrubbers win over upgrading projects – expert

Subscribe

To our FREE newsletter
Get all the latest maritime news delivered straight to your inbox.

HSFO demand firm as scrubbers win over upgrading projects – expert

Contrary to initial expectations and despite the thrust on cleaner marine fuels due to the International Maritime Organization’s global low sulfur mandate, the high sulfur bunker fuel market has remained strong as scrubbing remains a favorable option, global research and consulting company BLUE Insight’s director Adrian Tolson said.

Very low sulfur fuel oil currently represents 60%-65% of global bunker demand and sufficient supply exists. But VLSFO demand will likely drop as alternatives enter the market and additional scrubbers will be installed, Tolson said in a pre-recorded video for the 37th Asia Pacific Petroleum Conference, or APPEC 2021, organized by S&P Global Platts from Sept. 27-29.
When IMO 2020 came up, shipowners had two routes to compliance — install scrubbing technology and continue to buy HSFO, or use compliant VLSFO fuel in main engines.

The debate in shipping was actually quite heated and controversial, with shipowners holding two very divergent views, Tolson said.

One view was that scrubber was the best choice as HSFO would be much cheaper and refiners were not likely to invest in upgrading to VLSFO production.

The other was that many shipowners felt that there was an obligation on the suppliers and refiners to ensure that shipowners could find high quality low-priced compliant VLSFO, and it was not the shipowner’s responsibility to have a “mini-refinery” on their vessel, he added.

“Despite the pre-2020 Hi-5 spread, uncertainty regarding the Hi-5 spread and lack of liquidity on the forward curve limited major upgrading and investment decisions prior to 2020,” Tolson said.

“The scrubber decision was a little bit easier because worried refiners and suppliers were willing to commit to medium test formula-based contracts for potentially depressed HSFO,” he said, adding that scrubbers continue to win over refinery desulfurization and upgrading projects.

In Singapore, the world’s largest bunkering port, Tolson noted that HSFO demand has remained strong. This is also reflected in other ports worldwide although there is a “heavier demand” for HSFO in Singapore compared to smaller ports because bigger ships come to Singapore, he said.

In August, Singapore’s sales of high sulfur bunker fuel, which includes 180 CST, 380 CST and 500 CST bunker fuel, were up 2.7% year on year to 1.057 million mt, or 25.9% of the total sales in August, up from 24.6% a year earlier, latest data from the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore showed.

In general, HSFO has reduced the need for low sulfur bunkers as the market is taking advantage of the cheaper cost of scrubbing, Tolson said, adding that the key Hi-5 spread will likely stay narrow for the foreseeable future.

In Singapore, this spread averaged $298.90/mt in January 2020 as the market transitioned to the IMO 2020 mandate, Platts data showed. It narrowed to average as low as $60.32/mt in September 2020, but recovered to average $103.33/mt in January 2021, according to Platts data. On a monthly basis, the spread has remained mostly over $100/mt on an average so far this year and averaged $82.59/mt from Sept. 1-27.

Scrubbing, a rewarding solution

Looking at a Neopanamax open loop scrubber payback scenario for a 15,000-16,000 TEU vessel, it is still a $6.5 million investment and there is a certain amount of time lost in installing scrubbers, Tolson said.

If one looks at the period around February 2020, it took less than 1 year to payback an investment in scrubbers then. The payback now is about 3 years but it is still an attractive payback, Tolson said.

The argument of putting a scrubber on board and burning HSFO on bigger ships and on newbuilds is even more compelling, Tolson said.

“Newbuilds aren’t retrofits. You can build a scrubber into a new vessel that costs much less than you can by retrofitting… So, in one and a half years you can have a payback on any scrubber investment, Tolson said.

It is also useful to carry out a cost comparison between upgrading projects and scrubbing. Upgrading projects can take place in a refinery or on a standalone basis and the cost of these depends on size — capacity throughput, location and how much needs to be built, Tolson said.

“I’m assuming here 2 options where a project to create a 50,000 b/d processing unit would cost you somewhere between $500 million to a $1 billion … and I’m assuming a 7 year payback on both the scrubber and refinery upgrade or the standalone unit,” Tolson said.

“What you can see from this is that a scrubber retrofit on container ships is about 50%-35% of the cost of upgrading projects, which makes upgrading high sulfur fuel oil to low sulfur highly uncompetitive for the majority of large ships,” Tolson said.

So, upgrading is not justified from a pricing perspective, Tolson said, noting that scrubbing emerged as the winner in the processing versus scrubbing debate.

Source: Platts

Related Posts

Video

Finance & Economy
Shipping News
Ports

LNG boosts CPLP 2022 results

Capital Product Partners L.P. released its financial results for the fourth quarter ended December 31, 2022. Highlights  Three-month periods ended December 31, 20222021Increase/(Decrease)Revenues$79.9 million$63.6 million26%Expenses$42.1 million$35.7...

Keppel Corp posts 9% drop in full-year profit

Singapore’s Keppel Corp said on Thursday its net profit for the year fell 9%, partly hurt by weak performance from its urban development business...

Stolt-Nielsen sees Q4 profits rise on strong markets

Stolt-Nielsen Limited reported unaudited results for the fourth quarter and full year 2022. The Company reported a fourth-quarter net profit of $95.3 million, with revenue...

Euronav delivers better-than-expected Q4 revenue

Euronav NV reported its non-audited financial results for the fourth quarter ended 31 December 2022. Hugo De Stoop, CEO of Euronav said: “Constrained vessel supply...

Wartsila: A challenging year with strong annual growth

HIGHLIGHTS FROM OCTOBER–DECEMBER 2022 Order intake decreased by 24% to EUR 1,638 million (2,150)Service order intake increased by 6% to EUR 791 million (747)Net sales...

Baltic index hits over 2-year trough on waning demand for larger vessels

The Baltic Exchange’s dry bulk sea freight index dropped to its lowest level in...

Luxury Cruise Market Holds Much Promise For Greek & East Med Hidden Gem Destinations

The appeal of Greece and the East Mediterranean as an ideal region for luxury...

Baltic index falls to over 2-year low as larger vessel rates slide

The Baltic Exchange’s dry bulk sea freight index fell to its lowest since June...

Baltic index logs worst month in 3 years

The Baltic Exchange’s main sea freight index registered its biggest monthly percentage fall in...

Baltic index snaps 9-day losing streak as panamax, supramax rates rise

The Baltic Exchange’s main sea freight index snapped its nine-session losing streak on Tuesday,...

DP World wins bid for development of a mega-container terminal at India’s Deendayal Port

DP World has won a major concession to develop, operate and maintain the mega-container terminal at Deendayal port in Gujarat, on the western coast...

Luxury Cruise Market Holds Much Promise For Greek & East Med Hidden Gem Destinations

The appeal of Greece and the East Mediterranean as an ideal region for luxury cruising will be one of the main highlights of the...

Port of Los Angeles proposes cruise terminal project

The Port of Los Angeles is inviting comments on a draft Request for Proposals (RFP) for the future development of a new Outer Harbor...

Port of Long Beach Closes 2022 with Second-Busiest Year

The Port of Long Beach marked its second-busiest year on record by moving 9.13 million twenty-foot equivalent units in 2022, allowing for a return...

Hapag-Lloyd AG acquires share in J M Baxi Ports & Logistics Limited

Hapag-Lloyd AG signed a binding agreement today under which it will acquire 35% of J M Baxi Ports & Logistics Limited (JMBPL) from a...